Sure it does, Gunnar. A Television Series is not a movie. Its not about who didn't rate it, it is about accurately defined data.

Skip

I absolutely think it adds value. First of all it is more accurate.... and to me accuracy = significant Plus For those of us that do collect a crap-load of television (I collect just as much TV release as I do movies... if not more)... I hope this will help with the filtering and such some day soon.

so like Merrik I am happy to see them come through! And I put through as many as I can find myself. Though I will add/correct other stuff with it when I see it needs it... if there is nothing else I see the profile needs I will not think twice about uploading it by itself.

For knowing that it was made for Television, we have Television as a genre.

The Film/Television rating system just tells us what rating system was used. If it's Not Rated, then no rating system was used. So it's pretty meaningless information.

I don't mind people changing it as part of a wider contribution. I just feel that it's not really useful to clutter the contribution system with this change alone.

Quoting GSyren:

Quote:
For knowing that it was made for Television, we have Television as a genre.

The Film/Television rating system just tells us what rating system was used. If it's Not Rated, then no rating system was used. So it's pretty meaningless information.

I don't mind people changing it as part of a wider contribution. I just feel that it's not really useful to clutter the contribution system with this change alone.

You have to remember not everyone thinks the way you do. Just because it is meaningless information to you does not mean it is meaningless information to everyone. Having the NR rating in the correct rating system makes it more accurate (in my opinion)... it being more accurate makes it a significant change (once again in my opinion). Ken put the NR rating in both rating systems... that alone tells me that it is meant to be used. We have a rating filter which will hopefully take all rating systems into account before too long. Then there will be even more reason to use it then there is now.

Ok, I guess we just disagree on this.

To me, this is as useless as knowing if my black coffee is without milk or without cream.

The correct way to do this - in my opinion- would have been to disable Rating System when Not Rating was selected. That would have been correct information; the title is not rated therefore no rating system was used.

And now it is part of the rating system, Gunnar.

Skip

Quoting 8ballMax:

Quote:
Quoting GSyren:

Quote:
For knowing that it was made for Television, we have Television as a genre.

Well, some of us dissagree with Television being a genre in the first place. Afterall, television is not a genre, it's a medium.

Have to agree with you there.  It's the same with anime and animation, both are also mediums, not genres.

Quoting GSyren:

Quote:
Quoting Dr Pavlov:

Quote:
And now it is part of the rating system, Gunnar.
Skip

That's like saying that milk and cream are both dairy products, but that doesn't make them any more relevant when it comes to black coffee.

Film Ratings and Televison Ratings are both part of the rating system, but doesn't make them relevant to a Not Rated title.

Some of us sees value in the information.