Quoting surfeur51:

Quote:
Quoting nimrod85:

Quote:
Yes, but not everybody is thinking that ^^

I like your idea. In fact Ken allows himself to improve the program, but for some users, improving rules is forbidden... Rules are above everything... even common sense.

I like them too and I really don't understand why anyone would want to use the same cover art multiple times.

Quoting Daddy DVD:

Quote:
I like them too and I really don't understand why anyone would want to use the same cover art multiple times.

Because a "cover" is just that:  the (front and back) covers of the box the disc came in.  If all the discs are in one box, there is one cover.  They aren't "disc" images, they're "cover" images.

---------------

Just like everything there will be 2 groups... one that likes it one way (as rules are now) and one that likes it another (the way nimrod85 likes it). Who is to say if or when something should change... and then if it does change and we get people on the other side complaining... does it then have to be looked at to be changed back?

No matter how the rules says it has to be... it will not satisfy everyone. In my opinion his images are terrible for cover images... and 2 of the images can't even be considered covers in any sense of the word since they are of the discs themselves. But that being said... I downloaded his images anyway... even though I would never consider them for the cover images... I will keep them in the gallery window for addition images.

Quoting CalebAndCo:

Quote:
When I get around to working on this title myself, I'll probably keep the front cover on the child profiles and replace the back cover with the inside pic for the individual film.  But since that is not contemplated by the rules, I will not submit them.

Well, this is an interesting thought.  The rule says, "If a film is individually packaged, use the cover images from that packaging."

If the inner packaging has a back, but not a front, can we use the back from the inner and the front from the outer?

See, I said people could find areas where it would be ideal to update the rules

I personally see "individually packaged" as having a boxset that then has separate boxes within. These could house more than one disc. However, I can see it as north said that some would see it other ways.

Quoting nimrod85:

Quote:
Rules can be changed

Not by you and surfeur. And certainly not by not following the rules.

Skip

Quoting Daddy DVD:

Quote:

Unfortunately or fortunately voting is not a democracy, so if a minority follows the rules the majority just has to swallow it.

 

And that remembers me a recent very wise remark from northbloke:

Quoting northbloke:

Quote:
I agree, it's refreshing sometimes to have someone with a new outlook on the rules and the database, to point out flaws we've missed or learned to live with.

PS. It seems that I quoted something before it was sent... 

Quoting Daddy DVD:

Quote:
Unfortunately or fortunately voting is not a democracy, so if a minority follows the rules the majority just has to swallow it.

Rules are there for everyone, like it or not you don't have to swallow rules, just follow them!